Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery

Let me just say — Romanelli’s absolutely nailed it. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with genuine smiles and that classic small-town hospitality that instantly makes you feel like family. The staff here aren’t just friendly — they actually care about what they’re serving and about the people they’re serving it to. You can tell they take real pride in their work, and that sense of warmth carries right through to the food. When I opened the box, I knew I was in for something special. That aroma — fresh dough, bubbling cheese, and perfectly balanced tomato sauce — is the kind of smell that stops you in your tracks. What I found inside was a textbook example of what a New Jersey pizza should look like: a beautifully golden, slightly blistered crust with just the right char around the edges, a bright layer of sauce peeking through, and a smooth, even blanket of melted mozzarella stretching from slice to slice. The first bite confirmed everything. The crust had that perfect crunch when you fold it, yet still soft and chewy on the inside — absolute perfection. The sauce was rich and flavorful, with that ideal balance of tang and sweetness, while the cheese had just the right stretch and saltiness. Each ingredient complemented the other, no part overpowering — just pure harmony in every bite. What really sets Romanelli’s apart, though, is the consistency and care they put into every pie. You can tell this isn’t some rushed, assembly-line pizza. This is made by people who know what they’re doing, who’ve mastered the art of simplicity done right. From the crisp edge to the center of the pie, every bite delivered that nostalgic, old-school, New Jersey flavor that’s getting harder to find these days. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or taking home a whole pie to share, Romanelli’s is one of those rare spots where everything just feels right — from the friendly faces behind the counter to the unforgettable pizza they serve. If you’re anywhere near Madison, do yourself a favor and grab a pie from Romanelli’s. It’s the kind of place that reminds you why you fell in love with pizza in the first place.

Not only does Romanellis serve authentic Northern NJ pie, a rarity in itself, but rarer still, a variety of *vegan* meat and cheese options! Tasty vegan cheese, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage crumbles, and vegan chicken cutlet are all on the menu. We were surprised and delighted today when we received, along with our vegan pie, a delicious vegan chicken sandwich topped with balsamic and arugula; this item was listed as simply a "chicken cutlet" under the Side Orders section of the web takeout menu. We will definitely be ordering again soon!

1 large pizza and an order of wings. This is truly a hidden gem in Madison, I would've never known. I stopped in to pick up my to go order for dinner. 1 slice of pizza ended up being 4 slices and 4 pieces of wings. The pizza was nice and thin, and the crust was baked well! Nicely done very close to NY pizza. I will definitely try again!

We went for dinner at Romanellis last night to support a local organization (they do a ton of these fundraisers for local groups) and I had a fan favorite - the Caesar salad - and my daughter had the penne Vodka. The best thing about the Caesar are the croutons - made from breadsticks! And my kids would eat the penne vodka every day if they had the chance. Finally if you’re craving a pie, be sure to try the square grandma’s version- it’s definitely one of my favorites in the area.

I got a spinach and cheese pizza cooked perfectly delivered in a timely fashion priced fairly the crust was perfect. Very flavorful with garlic, I am so glad to have found them. I’ll try their other foods as well. Enjoy! Chrisb

Another great dinner - mushroom pizza custom made very thin.

The best pizza I've ever had! Lovely thin crust, perfect sauce to cheese ratio. It's my son's favorite pizza shop and he's a picky eater. The service is great too! They are friendly and accommodating.

Delicious pizza and great service! Deserve a come back. I truly enjoyed the food and atmosphere in the restaurant, so did my family and friends.